Justice and law can be two faces of the same coin; however, this is not always correct in most circumstances. According to the philosopher Lycophron who said " law is a contract and surety (to guarantee) to one another their rights, but not sufficient to make the citizens themselves good and just" (Cooper, 2007). He believed that laws were written to be enforced on people in order to control their freedom. Moreover, the law have not provided enough justice to the society since criminals are motivated to break it.
_02C.jpg)
Nowadays, the scenario is almost the same as how he defined justice will be. As a matter of fact, Dr.Popper said about justice " It is the most fitting expression of the humanitarian" (Popper, 2011). Humans are blessed for having the ability to choice their life paths since we have braincells to define what's wrong and right. We have the instinct to be honest and respectful because this is how we want others to treat us. Additionally, the relationship between "just laws" and "just citizens" by Lycophron is limited by our boundaries. For example, Robin Hood was an outlaw since he did not follow the law of Nottingham and he was stealing from the rich and donate it to the poor. He was being against the law of his country;however, he was has his own law of the greenwood (Wright, 2013). His law consists of protecting the people who are in need even if it means that he will have to robe some money from the nobles. I believe his good intentions are justifying his actions regardless of the harm that is being done.
In conclusion, Lycophron's theory about justice and law is controversial for several years. Both sides have valid arguments, yet the decision is based on which perspective the reader is focusing on. Overall, justice is meant to provide a proper respectful life for the society wither it is written or not.
Works Cited:
Cooper, C. R. (2007). The Politics of Orality (Vol. 6). Leiden, Netherlands: Koninklijke Bill.
Popper, K. S. (2011). The Open Society and Its Enemies (Vol. VIII). Abingdon, England: Routledge.
Wright, A. W. (2013). A Beginner's Guide to Robin Hood. Retrieved Sept 30, 2015, from Bold Out Law: http://www.boldoutlaw.com/robbeg/
I sincerely agree with your point that different perspectives will make different outcomes. Really appreciate your official writing formula and you did a great job to use what was taught on the class!
ReplyDeleteThank you Bessy for your comment. I appreciate your feedback about my writing style.
Delete